At least 20 Georgia officials arrested for Flock misuseGA
Data misuse
Georgia's running total reached at least 20 public officials arrested statewide for misusing the Flock license-plate system, per Reason's Jul 31, 2026 tally -- the densest cluster of ALPR-misuse prosecutions anywhere in the country, and the aggregate behind the individual Georgia pins on this map. Institute for Justice attorney Michael Soyfer called it just the tip of the iceberg, arguing the reason misuse goes undetected nationwide is that plate searches run with almost no oversight -- routinely without reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or a warrant, sometimes logged under a rationale as thin as the words criminal justice. BOTH READINGS OF THE NUMBER, per the standing caveat on every misuse aggregate here: Flock introduced its AI Audit Assistance tool in April 2026 and says it has helped agencies find cases that would otherwise have gone undetected -- so part of the arrest wave is better detection, not worse behaviour. Soyfer's counter is on the record too: there is little public information on how the audit tools work, Flock's customer is the police department, and relying on them is leaving the police to police themselves -- reactive Whac-A-Mole where the Fourth Amendment prescribes a prophylactic warrant requirement. Courts have so far declined to require one for plate searches; the Norfolk plaintiffs are appealing. Pinned at Georgia's centroid as a statewide aggregate.
Deputy fired and arrested after plate-reader auditGA
Data misuse
The Habersham County Sheriff's Office in north Georgia announced on Jul 31, 2026 that Deputy Christian Brewer had been fired and arrested for misusing license-plate data -- the misuse, per NowGeorgia via Reason, involving an individual with whom Brewer had a personal relationship at the time. The same shape as Springville AL and the Washington Post's national pattern: not a wrong plate or an overbroad dragnet, but an officer pointing a public surveillance network at someone in his own life. Surfaced by an audit rather than a complaint, which cuts both ways -- the audit worked, and every department without one shows a clean record that proves nothing. One of at least 20 Georgia arrests in the statewide wave.
71 percent of felony alerts misread the plateCA
Wrongful stop
The accuracy number behind every wrongful-stop record on this map: an analysis of alerts sent to the Roseville Police Department found that in 71 percent of cases where Flock flagged a vehicle as stolen or tied to a felony, the system had misread the license plate -- 1,427 alerts over 2023-2024, per Business Insider via Gizmodo. Roseville PD had reported bad reads to Flock dozens of times over four years, and spent roughly $450,000 on the system. BOTH SIDES, in full: Flock called the figure a mischaracterization, said performance has significantly improved (Roseville PD disputes that), blamed a unique deployment -- older hardware, non-standard mounting higher and farther from vehicles than recommended, and rear-only scanning the city chose to avoid capturing faces -- and cited its own testing of over 99 percent capture and over 96 percent OCR accuracy in optimal conditions. Read that defence carefully, because it concedes the asymmetry: the system is extremely accurate at logging every passing car into the searchable database, and far less accurate in the moment it accuses a specific driver. Roseville says it never stopped or arrested anyone on a bad scan. Other departments were not as careful -- the Institute for Justice counts at least 27 drivers pulled over, detained at gunpoint, or jailed on Flock misreads, including an Arkansas family held at gunpoint over a one-letter misread and a San Diego man jailed nearly a month over a car that was five miles from the crime.
Misuse allegations in at least 12 statesUS
Data misuse
Newsweek's Jul 30, 2026 review of criminal cases, internal investigations and disciplinary actions found officers accused of misusing Flock license-plate systems in at least TWELVE states -- Alabama, California, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Kansas, Missouri, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, Texas and Wisconsin -- with the dominant pattern being personal: tracking romantic partners, relatives or acquaintances. This is the national frame for the state pins around it, and it carries the company's own position at the top: founder and CEO Garrett Langley told Newsweek the cases are disappointing but show the system working -- accountability regardless of the badge -- and said the Audit Assistance tool was built after customers and communities demanded more responsibility. The standing caveat cuts the same way it always does: detection tooling arriving in April and arrests clustering in the months after is consistent with better auditing, not just worse behaviour, and departments without the tooling prove nothing by their clean records. The pushback is now federal as well as local: Rep. Thomas Massie introduced legislation to deny certain federal funding to agencies using Flock readers, and Republican lawmakers in several states have filed bills limiting retention, restricting sharing agreements, or forcing transparency. The ACLU's Chad Marlow put the underlying stake plainly in earlier comments: tracking a vehicle over time reveals deeply personal information about the person driving it. Pinned at the US centroid as a national aggregate.
DA investigator charged over 60+ searchesGA
Data misuse
Andrae Wright, an investigator with the Ogeechee Circuit District Attorney's Office northwest of Savannah, was arrested Jul 27, 2026 and charged with illegally accessing the Flock license-plate system more than 60 times between Jun 15 and Jul 5, per the GBI via WSB-TV. The detail that distinguishes this from the officer cases surrounding it: Wright worked for a PROSECUTOR'S office -- the arrest wave that began with deputies and patrol officers has reached the offices that charge them. Sixty-plus searches in three weeks is also not a moment of weakness; it is a pattern that ran daily until an audit caught it. The twentieth-or-so entry in Georgia's statewide arrest count, and the reason the aggregate record above carries the detection-versus-behaviour caveat.
Fayetteville fires 3 officers over Flock searchesGA
Wrongful stop
The Fayetteville Police Department fired three officers on July 17, 2026 after a new auditing feature for its Flock cameras flagged searches outside the scope of their work, including officers running their own plates or those of friends and family with no legitimate law-enforcement purpose. The three were placed on administrative leave before being terminated, and the Georgia Bureau of Investigation opened a criminal inquiry. The department said it would not speculate about the officers' intent.
DeKalb deputy jailed for Flock misuseGA
Data misuse
DeKalb County sheriff's Sgt. Kabiru Salawu, employed since 2009, was fired and jailed without bond on July 17, 2026 after an internal investigation found he used Flock license-plate technology for unauthorized purposes. He faces charges of violation of oath of office and misuse of license-plate data. Sheriff Melody Maddox said misusing law-enforcement technology for any unauthorized purpose is a serious breach of public trust. THE CONTRACT BEHIND THE CASE: DeKalb County commissioners approved a ten-year, sole-source Flock agreement worth close to $19 million in a single sitting, branded Digital Shield, spanning license plate readers, AI-enabled drones and surveillance cameras -- the largest single Flock commitment recorded in this dataset, adopted with promises of transparency and ethical data use. This felony case is that rollout's first. How it surfaced matters for every misuse count on this map: Flock has deployed an AI audit-assistance feature that flags queries falling outside a department's stated policy and routes them to supervisors instead of leaving misuse to manual log review, and company spokesperson Paris Lewbel has pointed to the resulting wave of firings as the system working as intended. If detection improved, some share of the 2026 misuse surge is better auditing rather than more abuse -- and departments without the tooling are not cleaner, only blinder.
Fort Bend lieutenant ran plates for personal useTX
Data misuse
Documents obtained by ABC13 show a Fort Bend County Sheriff's Office lieutenant used Flock cameras to look up one license plate 41 times and another 148 times between January 2022 and December 2025, admitting the searches were not tied to official work. A resident had complained the lieutenant was stalking them; internal affairs found a violation of general orders tied to a contentious family relationship and suspended the lieutenant for two days. No criminal charges were filed and the lieutenant was not named.
Junction City weighs Flock trial amid oppositionOR
Wrongful stop
Junction City is considering a 90-day free trial of eight Flock cameras, drawing civil-liberties objections at a mid-July 2026 council meeting where residents warned the system would build a searchable record of ordinary people's movements. It follows Eugene, Springfield and Lane County cutting ties with Flock and a 2026 Oregon law adding data-retention limits, encryption and sanctuary-law compliance for plate readers. No decision was made; the council set further discussion for August 11.
ACLU sues Huntington over $2.1M Flock contractWV
Wrongful stop
One day after the Huntington City Council approved a $2.1 million Flock Technologies surveillance contract on a 6-4 vote -- following a meeting that ran past 4 a.m. and more than 50 public comments against it -- the ACLU of West Virginia, the Haslam Law Firm and Glazer, Saad and Anderson sued the city in Cabell County Circuit Court on behalf of resident Greg Jimison. The suit seeks to void the deal, arguing the city ignored its own procurement rules and that city code bars letting a private company use city property for commercial purposes without public notice and a hearing. The contract covers plate-recognition cameras, vehicle-fingerprint technology, live video, gunshot detection and automatically dispatched drones.
Officer fired over a plate-reader searchAL
Data misuse
Moody Police Chief Reece Smith confirmed that an officer was terminated on Jul 16, 2026 after an internal investigation opened Jul 10 found a violation of the department's license plate reader policy. The officer was placed on leave immediately and fired three days later; the findings went to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency, which decides whether criminal charges follow. The department declined to name the officer or describe the violation, citing personnel policy, so what the search was FOR is not on the public record. Smith said Moody has run the cameras since 2019 and called this the city's first breach, while defending the system as a valuable investigative tool. Mayor Nick Rutledge issued a statement backing the chief and the department. Recorded as an outcome, not an allegation: the discipline is confirmed, the underlying conduct is not disclosed, and the ALEA review was still open when this was written.
SF approves $3M Larsen gift to expand RTICCA
Wrongful stop
On July 15, 2026 the San Francisco Police Commission approved a $3 million gift from billionaire Chris Larsen's San Francisco Police Community Foundation to expand SFPD's Real Time Investigation Center, which tracks plates via hundreds of street cameras and dozens of drones and runs the city's 400 Flock cameras. The money funds drone docking stations, counter-drone technology and center infrastructure. The approval came days after WIRED reported that feeds from five SFPD surveillance drones had been left accessible on the open internet for more than seven months through a mishandled Skydio sharing link.
The contract lapsed; the cameras kept recordingCA
Wrongful stop
When the nation's third-largest police force let its Flock Safety contract expire on Jul 11, 2026, the 138 pole-mounted cameras in Los Angeles did not switch off. LAPD Cmdr. Randy Goddard told the Police Commission on Jul 14 that the cameras continue capturing plates and storing the results in Flock's cloud while city attorneys negotiate new terms, that the department cannot access any of it during the lapse, and that letting them run is deliberate -- once a new agreement is signed LAPD could go back and retrieve footage from the gap for investigations. Why this matters beyond one city: on this map, 'let the contract expire' is recorded dozens of times as an ending, and the assumption behind every one of those records is that expiry stops the collection. Here it did not. It stopped the department's ACCESS while the vendor's collection continued uninterrupted on public infrastructure, with the backlog explicitly preserved for retroactive retrieval. Pair it with Littleton MA, where cameras a town had ordered powered down were found switched back on by the vendor without notice: in both cases the municipality discovered that the switch it thought it controlled sits on the vendor's side. Any community whose campaign ends at non-renewal should ask what happens to the hardware and the feed on the day after.
LAPD lets Flock contract expire over privacyCA
Wrongful stop
On July 11, 2026 the Los Angeles Police Department -- the nation's third-largest police force and once one of Flock's largest government customers -- let its Flock Safety contract expire. Chief information officer Dean Gialamas said the decision was not about cost but about serious civil-liberties and civil-rights concerns over the privacy of the data the cameras collect. Thirty-nine Flock contracts were reported terminated nationwide in the first five months of 2026.
Officer resigned after searching a relativeAL
Data misuse
Springville Police Chief Jason Mize said an audit opened Jun 23, 2026 showed one of his officers had run multiple plate-reader searches on a family member in a single day. The relative was notified, and when the investigation closed the officer was called in and resigned on Jul 8, 2026. The findings were referred to the Alabama Law Enforcement Agency for a charging decision; the officer has not been publicly named. This is the cleanest form of the misuse pattern on this map -- not a wrong plate or a bad hit, but an officer using a city surveillance network to look at someone he knew. It surfaced through a routine audit rather than a complaint, which is the argument for mandatory audit trails and also the reason the true rate is unknowable in departments that do not run them. Springville is the second St. Clair County department in the same month to lose an officer this way.
Five officers arrested for misusing Flock dataGA
Data misuse
Five former Albany Police Department officers -- Tytianna Davis, Jade Jackson, Nicholas Richardson, Brittney Smith, and Issac Whitus -- were arrested on July 6, 2026 and charged with Misuse of License Plate Data and Violation of Oath of Office after an internal audit found they had accessed the city's Flock system for non-law-enforcement purposes; Richardson faced the most counts, 11. All five were fired and booked into the Dougherty County Jail. Flock called it the first publicly confirmed case in which its Audit Assistance records surfaced officer misconduct.
Deputy arrested for personal use of Flock camerasGA
Data misuse
Greene County, Georgia deputy Quinsha Goss was arrested July 7, 2026 and fired after a June 30 audit found she had queried the county's Flock system for personal reasons, running searches on at least one license plate over a three-month period with no law-enforcement justification.
Detective charged for Flock misuse after investigating a colleagueWI
Data misuse
Suspended Milwaukee police detective Tehrangi Chapman was charged in July 2026 with felony misconduct in public office for using the department's Flock license-plate system to track two people's movements 20 times, logging the fake search reasons 'test' and 'training.' Chapman had been one of the internal-affairs detectives who investigated former officer Josue Ayala's Flock misuse. Ayala, who searched an ex-partner and her boyfriend more than 200 times, was set to be sentenced a week after Chapman was charged.
Audit: 161 'accurate' Flock hits were not stolenCA
Wrongful stop
The LAPD Office of Inspector General's review of the department's ALPR system found that during the review period officers acknowledged 161 Flock alerts as accurate license-plate matches, yet later investigations determined the vehicles were not actually stolen -- the kind of stale hot-list hit that can drive unnecessary stops and wrongful detentions. The same review found the department could not produce contracts establishing Flock's data-sharing terms or Flock's access to Axon data, a governance gap the OIG flagged amid national scrutiny of third-party ALPR access. Put the number beside its counterpart: over the same period the OIG credited ALPR reads with recovering 337 stolen vehicles. So the department generated roughly one wrongful stop for every two recoveries, and it attributed those errors not to the cameras but to inaccurate or outdated information in law enforcement databases. The scale matters for reading the rest of this map -- the Institute for Justice could document only 27 wrongful ALPR stops nationwide across eight years, while a single department produced 161 in one review window. The national tallies are not measuring how often this happens, only how often somebody notices. LAPD runs 298 pole-mounted readers plus more than 1,600 mounted on or inside its vehicles, and its Axon and Motorola contracts remain active on the stated grounds that those vendors apply more stringent data safeguards.
The vendor swap: 53 cities drop Flock -- and Axon wins the contractsUS
Wrongful stop
The numbers behind the wave this map tracks city by city, and the denominators matter. Counting Flock alone: 53 municipalities have canceled or rejected Flock Safety contracts -- 39 terminations in the first five months of 2026 alone, per an Institute for Justice tally, across 28 states -- driven by unauthorized data access, changed terms, immigration-enforcement lookups, and cameras that stayed on after cities ordered them off. But most departures are vendor swaps, not surveillance retreats: Axon is winning the replacement contracts, and Denver is the model -- fewer cameras, shorter retention, no national database, mandatory audit trails, and the tracking continues under a fresher logo. Two January 2026 rulings, Schmidt v. City of Norfolk and State v. Simonson, upheld limited ALPR use while flagging scale, retention, and sharing scope as the constitutional variables -- exactly the ones contract language cannot lock across vendor cycles. New Hampshire's three-minute deletion rule and Vermont's approval regime are the standing proof that only state law survives a vendor swap. The independent Who Approved This tracker now documents 168 contracts across 46 states, 55 of them ended. The corporate backstory sharpens the point: Flock and Axon were previously integrating their technologies before a public split when Axon launched its competing plate reader -- and while Axon markets itself as running no national camera network, it holds multiple Department of Homeland Security contracts of its own. As one security researcher who documented Flock's vulnerabilities put it: 'I wouldn't see moving to Axon as an improvement.' The mechanics of the swap, documented July 2026: Flock crossed 100,000 cameras even as 53 cities canceled, and Axon -- which spent years feeding Flock plate data into its in-car systems before ending that partnership in early 2025 -- launched direct competitors to capture the exits: Axon Outpost, a pole-mounted reader, and Axon Lightpole, a streetlight retrofit built with Ubicquia, the same smart-streetlight vendor Flock uses. The pitch to cities is deliberate: similar capability, tighter contract terms, and seamless integration with the body cameras and Evidence.com cloud they already run. The civil-liberties case that the swap solves nothing rests on hard numbers -- the ACLU notes fewer than 1 percent of scanned plates connect to any alleged crime, and the LAPD's own inspector general flagged high rates of false stolen-vehicle alerts that put innocent drivers through stops. Jalopnik warns Axon's deeper integration may raise privacy risk rather than lower it, aggregating data far beyond a plate number. Counting every vendor, the tally is larger: on a July 8, 2026 press call the Institute for Justice put it at more than 113,000 ALPRs operating nationwide and at least 82 jurisdictions that have canceled ALPR contracts or taken the cameras down. Do not add those two numbers together or read one as a correction of the other -- 53 counts Flock cancellations and rejections, 82 counts ALPR departures across Flock, Axon, Motorola Solutions and the rest. IJ attorney Michael Soyfer, whose office brought both the Norfolk and San Jose suits, framed the Chatrie ruling as the Court focusing on the mass-surveillance character of these systems rather than on any single search. This map still adds only named, sourced places, which is why its own verified switch count stays well below every press figure above.
The credibility problem: Flock told cities it had no federal contracts. It did.US
Wrongful stop
The ACLU has assembled a pattern of Flock Safety giving false information to the city councils and police departments that buy its cameras. In Loveland, Colorado, told a police chief and the press that federal agencies had no access to local data and that federal sharing was moot because Flock held no federal contracts -- then admitted it had CBP and DHS pilot contracts granting direct access. In Oshkosh, Wisconsin, the council revoked approval one day after granting it -- the shortest approve-to-cancel span on record -- after concluding it had been given bad information. Denver's mayor negotiated secretly with what one council member called Flock's 'discredited CEO.' The through-line of the whole removal wave: cities aren't just worried about what the cameras do, they've stopped trusting what the vendor says they do.
At least 27 wrongful stops, and two thirds ended with guns already drawnUS
Wrongful stop
An Institute for Justice review of media reports and court records, published in July 2026, counted at least 27 cases since 2018 in which an ALPR error led to an innocent motorist being pulled over, detained or jailed -- the majority of them since 2023. The number that matters more than the count: in nearly two thirds of those cases officers did not realise the error until after they had drawn and pointed their guns. IJ attorney Michael Soyfer, who represents residents in the San Jose and Norfolk suits, put the stakes as every one of those stops being a high-risk encounter where a wrong move or a moment of fear can turn deadly, and nobody should have to prove their innocence at the roadside because a camera could not tell a zero from an O. The failure mode is mundane and mechanical: the readers confuse visually similar characters, 0 for O and 2 for 7, and get worse in rain, snow, mud and glare. Flock claims it captures 93 of every 100 plates accurately, which sounds tolerable until it is multiplied by the company's stated ambition of reading 20 billion plates a month -- that leaves well over a billion inaccurate reads in the same period. A police-conducted study in Vallejo, California found up to 37 percent of ALPR hits were erroneous. Separately, a six-month CBS News investigation verified more than a dozen wrongful stops plus several instances of the technology being abused outright. Read this alongside the individual records on this map: they are not isolated failures, they are the expected output of a system operating at that scale and that error rate.
A cancelled contract is not a removed cameraUS
Wrongful stop
Every `removed` entry on this map records a decision. It does not establish that the hardware left, and across 2025-26 the two came apart often enough to be a pattern rather than a series of delays. DeFlock Dane puts it flatly: physical removal is a separate question from the vote. Verona's contract lapsed in December and the cameras were still standing in January, until the mayor covered them with black plastic bags and Flock began removal in February. Dane County's subscription ended May 31, Flock did not remove the cameras, and on June 6 deputies bagged all 26 themselves. Oshkosh's police chief bagged his too. UW-Madison's contract ended June 26 and removal was announced July 3, yet the solar-powered cameras were still in place and uncovered afterward, with police able to say only that they assumed the cameras were no longer collecting. Guthrie OK cancelled effective February 18, 2025 and Flock did not schedule the uninstall until July 21, five months of cameras running free of charge. Macon County NC lost access to all 16 cameras on July 14 and they were still standing on July 21, with the school district hosting four of them saying nobody had contacted it. Fort Collins voted in June and the last of 15 cameras came down July 23, about six weeks later. Cleveland, Cambridge and Eugene all kept cameras live past termination. Syracuse took eight months. TWO SEPARATE FAILURES ARE BUNDLED HERE, and they need different fixes: the vendor controls the removal schedule and has no deadline in most contracts, and a covered or unpowered camera is not a verified-offline camera. For anyone reading this map to judge whether surveillance actually stopped somewhere, the vote is the beginning of the answer and not the end of it. Practical test for any new entry: is there a dated confirmation that the hardware is down, and who confirmed it -- the agency, the vendor, or a reporter who went and looked. TWO CHEAP VERIFICATION TOOLS, both vendor-published: Flock's own transparency portal lists departed agencies as "[Inactive]" -- Natick MA PD reads Inactive today -- so a departure can be confirmed, or a stale `removed` record caught, without hunting local coverage. And the same portal publishes each agency's sharing counts, which is how UW-Madison's 168 outbound and 467 inbound agency relationships were established. SEPARATELY, AND LARGER: a municipal cancellation never reaches private cameras. Framingham City Council Chair George King, on his own city's exit -- the cameras are everywhere, Home Depot and Lowe's have them in their parking lots, so they come off city streets without leaving the city. Denver's privately owned Flock cameras kept operating after the city removed all 110 of its own. Every `removed` pin on this map means police-operated cameras, and nothing more.
The vote you never get to attendUS
Wrongful stop
This map is organised around public decisions, which quietly assumes there was one. Often there is not. After Denver's council rejected a $666,000 Flock renewal, the city signed a $498,500 extension instead -- $1,500 below the threshold that would have required a council vote. In Westland, Michigan the police chief declined to bring an expiring contract to the council at all, so no vote was held and no roll call exists. In Dane County, Wisconsin the sheriff had signed with Flock without board approval in the first place, which is why the board could only reach the money and not the capability. The Who Approved This tracker, which records how each contract was authorised, finds 168 contracts across 46 states, 55 of them ended, $50.8M documented -- and that only 14 of 164 records state a funding source at all (6 grants, 4 general fund, 3 asset forfeiture, 1 ARPA). The other 150 show an approval but not the money, which matters because grant-funded programs die when the grant does rather than when the politics change: Guthrie, Oklahoma's Flock system was bought with a federal DOJ grant and ended when the grant ran out. Contracts are subscriptions, typically 2 to 5 years at $2,500-$3,000 per camera per year. For scale, an Institute for Justice tally counts communities in 28 states terminating Flock contracts between August 2021 and May 2026, 39 of those in the first five months of 2026 alone. The practical lesson for reading this map: absence of a cancellation vote is not evidence a program is uncontested, and the spending threshold, the renewal date and the funding source are often more decisive than any council debate.
The cancellation wave, counted three waysUS
Data misuse
The aggregate the town-by-town pins add up to, recorded with each tally's method because the counts differ by what is being counted. By CONTRACTS: 82 Flock contracts terminated across 28 states between Aug 2021 and May 2026, 39 of them in the first five months of 2026 alone -- an Institute for Justice tally. By GOVERNMENTS: the ACLU of Georgia put it at nearly 60 local governments cancelling or declining to renew in the year to Jun 2026, and counts more than 26 US cities with CCOPS ordinances requiring public process before surveillance tech is adopted. By TRACKER: whoapprovedthis.org documents 168 Flock contracts across 46 states, 55 ended, $50.8M in contract value, with typical terms of two to five years at roughly $2,500 to $3,000 per camera per year -- which is why renewal dates recur: most communities get another vote inside two years. By CAMERAS: the DeFlock project maps more than 122,000 ALPR cameras nationally and counts 95 cities that have rejected them. Treat any single figure as one method, not a settled total. TWO CAVEATS BELONG ON EVERY NUMBER HERE. First, the counts move weekly -- in one mid-July fortnight Cleveland extended 9-6, Warren renewed 4-3, Huntington approved 6-4 and four Michigan cities left, so the wave runs in both directions at once. Second, the parallel surge in officer-misuse firings partly reflects new detection rather than new behaviour: Flock's AI audit-assistance feature now flags queries outside a department's stated policy and routes them to supervisors, and the company itself points to the firing wave as proof the auditing works. A department with no such tooling shows a clean record and proves nothing. This record is pinned at Washington, DC as a national aggregate; the coordinate is a convention, not a location.
CMPD officer arrested over an unauthorized queryNC
Data misuse
Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Officer Seth Elliott was arrested after investigators alleged he ran an unauthorized license-plate query using both the Flock system and CJLEADS, North Carolina's statewide criminal-justice data service -- the detail that widens this beyond one vendor, because it shows the same officer reaching into two separate government databases for the same improper purpose. Local reporting on the arrest warrants described the search as an illegal Flock favor. Chief Estella Patterson called misuse of law-enforcement technology a betrayal of the public's trust and a violation of everything the profession stands for, and said anyone found to have violated that trust would be held accountable. One of the North Carolina entries in the twelve-state pattern; date approximate to the month of the reporting.
Village chief tracked six people via plate readersIL
Data misuse
The police chief of Holiday Hills, Illinois, who also worked part-time for the Prairie Grove department, was arrested in June 2026 and charged with official misconduct after prosecutors said he used Prairie Grove's Flock system and a state law-enforcement database to track six people he knew personally, including three women he had been in relationships with. The case, reported by the surveillance-industry outlet IPVM, extends a documented pattern of officers using plate readers to follow partners and rivals.
Geofence dragnet swept a neighborhood for one robberVA
Wrongful stop
To solve a 2019 bank robbery in Midlothian, Virginia, police used a Google geofence warrant covering a 150-meter radius that swept up every device near homes, businesses, and a church. Okello Chatrie was identified and convicted, and in 2026 his case became the first geofence-warrant dispute heard by the Supreme Court. Decided June 29, 2026: the Court held 6-3 that acquiring Google Location History through a geofence warrant is a Fourth Amendment search. Justice Kagan wrote for the majority, joined by Roberts, Sotomayor, Jackson, and Kavanaugh; Gorsuch concurred but would have reached the same place on a property theory, treating the location history as Chatrie's own even while it sat on Google's servers. Alito dissented, joined by Thomas and in part by Barrett, calling the majority an irresponsible escapade that would send seismic waves through Fourth Amendment doctrine while changing nothing about Chatrie's own case. The operative move is narrow and large at once: the Court dropped the temporal floor Carpenter had built in, so the question is no longer how many days of location data the government took. What the Court did not do is decide whether this warrant was any good. Particularity, probable cause, and the scope of the government's discretion all go back to the Fourth Circuit, and the good-faith exception -- which the lower courts split on -- was left untouched, meaning Chatrie can win the doctrine and still lose the suppression motion. For this map the relevant reach is sideways rather than downward: a geofence warrant and an ALPR network do the same thing, sorting everyone who passed a place at a time in order to find one person, and the ruling supplies the reasoning that warrantless plate-reader dragnets have so far avoided.
Officer ran Flock about 179 times to track his exWI
Data misuse
Former Milwaukee police officer Josue Ayala searched Flock plate readers about 179 times over two months to track his ex-girlfriend and a second victim, a fellow officer who was dating her. He resigned and pleaded guilty to attempted misconduct in public office, and the court granted restraining orders to both victims.
Deputy ran a plate for personal reasonsGA
Data misuse
A Richmond County deputy, Jaquarius Yarbrough, was arrested and fired after a routine Flock audit found he had run at least one license plate over a 28-day period for personal reasons with no law enforcement purpose. He was charged with violation of oath of office and unlawful retention of plate-reader data.
Chief used Flock 140-plus times to stalk a manIL
Data misuse
A Prairie Grove, Illinois officer who later became a nearby police chief was charged with official misconduct after using Flock to track a man 140 times, 86 of them while off duty. Audit logs also showed the agency ran roughly 2,600 searches labeled 'training' against the live national network over five months before the conduct was caught.
Out-of-state agencies searched SF data via a fusion centerCA
Data misuse
San Francisco police cut outside access to their Flock network after an audit found roughly 300 improper out-of-state and federal queries routed through the NCRIC fusion center and a regional information network, despite a California law barring such sharing. Earlier reporting had found more than 1.6 million out-of-state searches of the city's data, at least 19 flagged as ICE-related.
Class action over plate readers at UC MercedCA
Data misuse
A California class action alleges Motorola's Vigilant plate readers at the entrance of UC Merced recorded everyone driving by, and that an April 2026 audit found the data was shared with federal agencies including Customs and Border Protection in violation of state law.
Three deputies charged after an ALPR auditGA
Data misuse
Three Cherokee County Sheriff's Office deputies -- Lt. Chris Bryant, Sgt. Mike Creeden, and Deputy Cynthia Jodesty -- were fired, arrested, and charged in June 2026 with felony violation of oath of office and a misdemeanor license-plate-data offense after the agency's own Real-Time Intelligence Division audited the ALPR system and found they had run searches for non-law-enforcement purposes.
Regional center made 299 improper queries of city camerasCA
Wrongful stop
In June 2026, San Francisco's police chief disclosed that a compliance audit found the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center had queried the city's Flock network on behalf of federal and out-of-state agencies -- 299 improper inquiries over about a year, in violation of California's ALPR Privacy Act. SFPD cut off the access and opened an internal review.
Deputy arrested for off-duty Flock searchesGA
Wrongful stop
Richmond County (Augusta), Georgia deputy Jaquarius Yarbrough was arrested and fired after a June 25 audit found he had run multiple Flock license-plate queries over a 28-day period with no authorized law-enforcement need.
Two supervisors charged over ALPR misuseGA
Data misuse
The Cherokee County, Georgia Sheriff's Office charged and fired two of its supervisors for allegedly misusing the county's automated license plate reader system, weeks before a similar case in Albany.
Journalist boxed in by police after a Flock plate errorMN
Wrongful stop
The Drive journalist Joel Feder was tracked for days by Plymouth, Minnesota police via Flock license-plate cameras and then boxed in by four squad cars, with a drone overhead, in a Kohl's parking lot in late June 2026. A manufacturer plate on his press-fleet Range Rover (34 10 DTM) was misread as a plate reported lost in Los Angeles that a police report had truncated to '34 DTM.' Flock's system flagged every Jaguar Land Rover fleet car sharing the 34 ## DTM format as stolen nationwide, and four other such cars were being tracked around Minnesota that week.
Blue Island PD -- NCIC 'Immigration Violator File' enabled in FlockIL
Data misuse
EFF investigator Dave Maass reported on Jun 25, 2026 that the Flock Safety ALPR administrative interface carries a drop-down where an agency subscribes to FBI NCIC topics, and that one of those topics is the Immigration Violator File. Blue Island Police Department was one of two agencies EFF confirmed had it enabled, so every plate its cameras read was matched against a federal immigration target list -- turning cameras a council approved for stolen-vehicle recovery into an immigration screening tool, without the checkbox ever appearing on an agenda. READ THE DENOMINATOR BEFORE READING THE FINDING: of at least 13 agencies that had answered EFF's public-records requests by Jun 25, 2026, two had this hotlist enabled and eleven had it switched off, across a Flock network of more than 5,000 communities with the investigation still open. Two confirmed cases and eleven confirmed negatives is not evidence of prevalence; the several thousand agencies that have not answered are the actual finding. HOW THE PLUMBING RUNS, because it is not a direct ICE feed: Flock told EFF that local agencies add and remove plates, that the FBI curates the NCIC list and pushes it to subscribing agencies, and that once it leaves the FBI the bureau sees only additions and removals rather than the alerts themselves. A hit goes to the municipal agency, which decides whether to call ICE. The Immigration Violator File is still populated exclusively by ICE -- the NCIC operator manual makes ICE the only agency authorised to enter or maintain records in it -- and its entries rest on administrative warrants issued by ICE agents without judicial review. That indirection is why the integration stayed invisible in procurement papers and transparency portals.
Sparks PD -- NCIC 'Immigration Violator File' enabled in FlockNV
Data misuse
EFF investigator Dave Maass reported on Jun 25, 2026 that Sparks Police Department had the FBI NCIC Immigration Violator hotlist toggled on in its Flock Safety configuration. The contradiction is the record: the department's own public ALPR transparency portal lists immigration enforcement among its prohibited uses, while its settings subscribed it to an immigration target list. One of two agencies EFF confirmed enabled. A written policy and a checkbox disagreed, and only the checkbox governed what the cameras did. READ THE DENOMINATOR BEFORE READING THE FINDING: of at least 13 agencies that had answered EFF's public-records requests by Jun 25, 2026, two had this hotlist enabled and eleven had it switched off, across a Flock network of more than 5,000 communities with the investigation still open. Two confirmed cases and eleven confirmed negatives is not evidence of prevalence; the several thousand agencies that have not answered are the actual finding. HOW THE PLUMBING RUNS, because it is not a direct ICE feed: Flock told EFF that local agencies add and remove plates, that the FBI curates the NCIC list and pushes it to subscribing agencies, and that once it leaves the FBI the bureau sees only additions and removals rather than the alerts themselves. A hit goes to the municipal agency, which decides whether to call ICE. The Immigration Violator File is still populated exclusively by ICE -- the NCIC operator manual makes ICE the only agency authorised to enter or maintain records in it -- and its entries rest on administrative warrants issued by ICE agents without judicial review. That indirection is why the integration stayed invisible in procurement papers and transparency portals.
Greer fires 2 officers after Flock auditSC
Data misuse
The City of Greer terminated police Corporal Kareem Lynch and Officer Sebastian Echeverry in late June 2026 after an AI-driven audit of the department's Flock license-plate system flagged that they had violated the agency's ALPR policy. The firings added to a growing national tally of officers disciplined for misusing plate-reader data.
Motorola/Vigilant class action: the OTHER ALPR giant in courtCA
Wrongful stop
Flock is not the only ALPR company being sued. On June 18, 2026 a class action was filed against Motorola Solutions and its subsidiary Vigilant, alleging the companies unlawfully shared California drivers' plate and location data across jurisdictions and with federal agencies -- naming Pleasanton, Sacramento, Modesto, Merced, and Livermore. Vigilant is the legacy ALPR heavyweight: EFF documented its database reaching up to 1,000 agencies and, via Digital Recognition Network, selling plate data to lenders, insurers, and debt collectors, while ICE has held a $22.8M contract for database access through 2026. The vendor names change; the surveillance model is the industry's, not one company's.
Ambushed over a test car's plateNE
Wrongful stop
Automobile journalist Tim Esterdahl was pulled over by police in Scotts Bluff after a Flock camera misread the license plate of a Range Rover he was testing. He wrote it up as being ambushed for no reason, and the significance is that he had the standing and the platform to trace the cause: systemic ALPR error rather than one bad read. A second automotive writer was tracked the same way in Plymouth, Minnesota the same month, also over a Range Rover test plate -- two cases in one month from the same niche, which says something about how many ordinary drivers experience this without ever learning why.
All Flock devices placed in the one Black neighborhoodPA
Data misuse
An audit of nearly three years of Flock logs found New Castle, Pennsylvania placed all 31 of its surveillance devices in the city's only majority-minority census tract, with officers adding scores of people to permanent private watchlists that carried no case numbers and were set never to expire.
Deputy stalked a woman he was interested inGA
Data misuse
Coffee County, Georgia deputy Chris Rozar was charged with multiple offenses after allegedly using the department's Flock system to stalk a woman he was romantically interested in, and was fired.
Deputy monitored an ex and her new partnerIL
Data misuse
Tyler Bryan, a former Winnebago County sheriff's deputy in Illinois, was charged with stalking and official misconduct after allegedly using the department's plate-reader system to monitor the locations of an ex-girlfriend and her new partner. The misconduct surfaced after the victims filed for an order of protection. It is among at least eighteen such cases compiled by the Institute for Justice.
Home Depot lots fed driver data to a police networkCA
Data misuse
A California class action alleges Home Depot's parking-lot plate readers covertly fed driver data into a national police database, and that Flock re-enabled nationwide sharing on Ventura County and Mountain View systems without authorization.
Flock demoed a playground, school, and kids' gym to other agenciesGA
Data misuse
A public-records request by Dunwoody resident Jason Hunyar revealed that Flock sales staff had tapped the Atlanta suburb's cameras -- including ones covering a children's gymnastics room, a playground, a school, a Jewish community center, and a pool -- to demonstrate the surveillance system to police departments around the country. Flock confirmed Dunwoody was part of its 'demo partner program.' The city renewed its Flock contract anyway.
EFF: without a warrant rule, police used ALPR hotlists for general trackingUS
Wrongful stop
An EFF analysis of millions of police searches of Flock ALPR data (May 2026) found a troubling pattern: with no warrant requirement to query the databases, agencies moved beyond specific investigations toward general, real-time tracking via 'hotlists' -- lists of vehicles flagged for live surveillance. It is the empirical backbone of the whole reform push: the problem isn't only who the data is shared with, it's that officers can watch anyone's movements without showing cause. No comprehensive federal ALPR statute exists; a 2025 Congressional Research Service brief confirms Congress has left the field to Fourth Amendment litigation and state law.
Flock's own lawyer: tracking an ex is "the most common thing"US
Data misuse
On a May 2026 radio appearance on Maine's Morning News, Flock Safety chief legal officer Dan Haley was asked about misuse and answered more plainly than the company's written statements ever have: very rarely, he said, someone does something stupid and uses it to figure out where an ex-girlfriend is, and that is actually the most common thing. IPVM caught it. Read against the record on this map, the concession matters twice over. It confirms from the vendor's own counsel that intimate-partner tracking is the leading misuse pattern, which is what the Institute for Justice's tally of at least 26 stalking cases already showed. And it sits awkwardly beside 'very rarely', given that departments almost never audit their own systems -- nearly every case on this map surfaced because a victim noticed, filed for a protective order, or went looking, not because anyone was watching the watchers. The exception proves the point: Joplin, Missouri only found its officer after the activist group DeFlock Joplin dug through records and found a single plate searched 395 times.
Officer pleaded guilty after tracking a mistressCA
Data misuse
Robert Jay Josett, 35, a Costa Mesa police officer, pleaded guilty in April 2026 after making 13 unauthorized inquiries beginning in 2023 through the California Law Enforcement Telecommunications System on people and vehicles unrelated to his job -- including his wife, his mistress, and men she dated -- and using Flock camera data to locate their vehicles and follow them, according to the Orange County District Attorney. The case drove the community push that put the city's 46-camera Flock contract back before the council in July 2026.
State high court struck down a geofence warrantMN
Wrongful stop
In State v. Contreras-Sanchez, the Minnesota Supreme Court ruled in 2026 that a geofence warrant violated the state constitution by giving police unchecked discretion over Google location data swept from everyone in an area.
Officer used Flock to track his mistressCA
Data misuse
An officer pleaded guilty after using Flock to track his mistress and her romantic interests
Flock staff viewed private cameras for sales demosGA
Data misuse
Records obtained by a Dunwoody, Georgia resident showed Flock sales employees accessed the city's camera network more than 1,000 times for product demos, including private Marcus Jewish Community Center cameras at a pool and children's gymnastics room, contradicting Flock's public pledge that no one from the company accesses customer footage. The mayor said Flock had been in places it should not, Flock apologized, and the council renewed the contract anyway.
Fifty days jailed despite an out-of-state alibiFL
Data misuse
Jalil Richardson was misidentified as a vehicle thief by Jacksonville Sheriff's Office facial recognition and held more than 50 days, even though time sheets showed he was at work in North Carolina. Charges were dropped.
ICE acknowledges using commercial phone-hacking spywareDC
Wrongful stop
In April 2026 ICE's acting director confirmed to Congress that the agency uses Paragon's Graphite spyware, which can silently compromise a phone with no user interaction and extract its contents; the Trump administration had reinstated the paused Paragon contract, and Democratic lawmakers pressed for answers about its use inside the United States.
Jailed 13 days for a fatal crash she was not atFL
Wrongful stop
Officers in Volusia County relied on a Flock capture to place an innocent driver's car at the scene of a deadly crash on Interstate 4. She was arrested and spent 13 days in jail before the charges were dropped. This is a human-error case rather than a misread: the camera recorded what it saw and officers drew the wrong conclusion from it. Thirteen days is among the longest wrongful detentions in the national tally, and it began with a photograph of a car.
2.5 million searches in six monthsCA
Data misuse
The number that shows what oversight is actually up against: data from San Jose's network of 474 Flock cameras was searched nearly 2.5 MILLION times in the last six months of 2025 -- an average of more than 15,000 searches per day -- with almost no oversight, per the Institute for Justice's complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief filed against the city in Apr 2026. At that volume, IJ's Fourth Amendment argument writes itself: no audit regime reviews fifteen thousand daily queries, so misuse detection at any scale is sampling, not supervision -- attorney Michael Soyfer's phrase is that it would be impossible to find all the misuse. The suit asks the court to treat plate-database mining as a search requiring a warrant, the same question the Kansas ALPR suit raises and the one Chatrie's geofence holding put on constitutional thin ice. Filed as an incident pending the case's outcome; date is the filing month.
Detective tracked his estranged wife and her suspected partnersKS
Data misuse
Kyle Rector, a detective in Bonner Springs, Kansas, allegedly used license plate readers to track his estranged wife and two men he suspected were her new romantic partners. He was charged with multiple crimes in March 2026. The case is part of the Institute for Justice's review of at least eighteen incidents of officers using automated plate readers to monitor people in their personal lives.
Officer tracked a woman he was datingWI
Data misuse
An officer resigned after running a woman he was dating through Flock nearly 180 times in two months
Detective tracked his estranged wifeKS
Data misuse
A detective was charged after tracking his estranged wife and two men he suspected she was seeing
A six-week-old alone in the car while both parents were cuffed at gunpointAR
Wrongful stop
On February 11, 2026 a Flock camera in Sherwood, Arkansas misread the plate on an SUV and Sherwood police ran a felony stop on the wrong vehicle. Officer Seth Kinkade drew his weapon and ordered the driver out; the driver complied calmly and was handcuffed. Officer Joe Lackey then arrived, drew his own firearm, and pulled the driver's partner from the car at gunpoint, cuffing her in front of the children in the vehicle. A six-week-old baby was left alone in a car seat in the back throughout. The correction came over the radio while officers were still walking to the rear of the car -- the dispatcher read the actual plate as ending '52'. They uncuffed the couple several minutes later. One officer's explanation on camera is the part worth keeping: those cameras are placed everywhere and they hit license plates, and he was not going to say they are completely perfect, because that is modern technology. The stop happened not far from a pair of Flock cameras.
Deputy tracked and pulled over a strangerFL
Data misuse
Lamar Roman, a Monroe County sheriff's deputy in the Florida Keys, allegedly used an automated plate-reader system to track and eventually pull over a woman he had met while working a security detail on a television production set. He was arrested in February 2026 and charged with accessing a computer or electronic device without authorization. The Institute for Justice highlights the case as a rare example of an officer targeting a complete stranger rather than a former partner.
Deputy tracked a woman he met on a TV setFL
Data misuse
A deputy tracked and pulled over a woman he had met while working security on a TV set
Federal agencies accessed city data without authorizationCA
Data misuse
Mountain View, California shut down all 30 of its Flock cameras in February 2026 after an audit found the ATF, the Air Force, and a GSA inspector general had accessed the city's surveillance data without authorization.
Covert federal plate readers disguised as traffic barrelsCA
Data misuse
EFF mapped more than 40 covert plate readers, many disguised as traffic barrels, that CBP and the DEA placed along San Diego and Imperial County highways, bypassing California's 2016 ALPR law. One resident with legal status was interrogated by agents about her casino trips.
1.6 million out-of-state searches of city camerasCA
Data misuse
Two events, one system. In Feb 2026 the Oakland firm Gibbs Mura filed a class action in San Francisco Superior Court alleging Flock let out-of-state and federal agencies search the SFPD ALPR database more than 1.6 million times over a seven-month period -- attorney David Berger told KTVU the sharing is illegal under California law, which bars giving ALPR data to out-of-state or federal agencies. The suit puts nearby Los Altos above a million outside searches, seeks statutory damages of $2,500 per violation, and names ICE, CBP, the FBI and ATF among querying agencies; Mountain View terminated its contract on finding violations, and El Cerrito audits twice found federal access, once after settings should have prevented it. Then in Jun 2026 SFPD's own routine compliance audit confirmed the mechanism from the inside: the Northern California Regional Intelligence Center had queried San Francisco's Flock network on behalf of federal and out-of-state agencies, with the same requests hitting between 531 and 763 other agencies simultaneously. SFPD said neither ICE nor DHS was identified among the requesters, shut off the access, and opened a review -- record both the allegation and the department's narrower audit finding, because they do not fully agree. The line that carries furthest is Flock's own: spokesperson Paris Lewbel told KTVU the searches were not a malfunction, platform issue, unauthorized access, or any failure of the Flock system. Nothing broke. The sharing was the product working as configured.
Amazon Ring cuts ties with Flock after Super Bowl adUS
Wrongful stop
Days after Flock Safety's February 2026 Super Bowl advertisement showed millions of Americans the true scale of its nationwide camera network, Amazon's Ring terminated its partnership with the company. The planned integration would have made it easier to feed Ring doorbell video into Flock's law-enforcement ecosystem; the swift corporate retreat under public backlash became one of the most visible moments of the anti-Flock wave and helped push the tally of canceled municipal contracts past 50.
Ring ends its Flock partnership after a Super Bowl ad backfiresUS
Wrongful stop
Ring ended its partnership with Flock Safety after an online backlash over a Super Bowl advertisement that promoted using an AI face scan to find lost pets. The ad was received with immediate scepticism: viewers pointed out that a tool which identifies a dog by its face can be turned on people just as easily, and that Ring's doorbell footprint plus Flock's plate network would join residential video to vehicle movement. The commercial argument is the notable part -- this was not a council vote, a lawsuit or a regulator, but a consumer brand deciding the association was not worth the reputational cost, which is a pressure point none of the municipal campaigns on this map can apply directly.
Officer tracked another officer and spouseFL
Data misuse
Niceville, Florida officer Coty Hall pleaded no contest after using the department's Flock system to track another officer and that officer's spouse. The misconduct was caught by an internal audit.
733,000 searches on a school district's 8 camerasTX
Data misuse
An investigation found that in a single month more than 3,100 police agencies ran over 733,000 Flock searches against eight cameras owned by one Texas school district, Alvin ISD. More than 620 searches were immigration-related, and agencies from Florida, Georgia, Indiana, and Tennessee ran immigration checks on a school parking-lot camera.
Former deputy charged with stalking via FlockGA
Data misuse
Chris Rozar, a former Coffee County sheriff's deputy in Georgia, was charged in 2026 with multiple criminal offenses after allegedly using the department's Flock system to stalk a woman he was romantically interested in. The case is among at least eighteen documented by the Institute for Justice of officers abusing plate-reader access for personal reasons.
Gwinnett officer arrested for tracking an exGA
Wrongful stop
Gwinnett County officer Renee Downer was arrested and relieved of duty in 2026 after allegedly using law-enforcement databases, including a license-plate reader system, to monitor the location of a former romantic partner. The case is among at least two dozen the Institute for Justice has documented in which officers used ALPR systems to track romantic interests.
Pasadena TX sergeant resigned over Flock stalking claimTX
Data misuse
Pasadena, Texas police Sergeant Michael Palitz resigned in 2026 while under investigation for allegedly using the department's Flock cameras to track and stalk a female officer, according to officials cited by KPRC 2. The case is part of a documented pattern of officers misusing plate-reader systems for personal reasons.
Air Force engineer charged with sawing down 13 Flock camerasVA
Wrongful stop
In Suffolk, Virginia, Jeffrey Sovern, a 41-year-old U.S. Air Force engineer and mechanic, was charged with taking down 13 Flock cameras with a saw. He pleaded not guilty to 25 counts: 13 felony counts of destruction of property, six counts of petit larceny, and six counts of possession of burglary tools. The case shows how far frustration with unaccountable plate-reader networks has escalated -- and sits alongside the lawful route the same state offers, where Norfolk's Flock network faces a Fourth Amendment challenge (Schmidt v. City of Norfolk).
Bad plate entry got a driver pulled over again and againCO
Wrongful stop
In the Denver suburb of Cherry Hills Village, Kyle Dausman was repeatedly pulled over after his license plate was mistakenly entered into the ALPR system. 'I continually get pulled over,' he told 9NEWS. 'I can't really use my truck in any fashion. I believe my safety is at risk. They zipped out of nowhere and immediately got behind me with the lights flashing.' A single bad database entry turned an automated dragnet into recurring police stops of an innocent driver.
Deputy used Flock to track an ex-fiancee's friendCA
Data misuse
Alexander Vanny, a Riverside County sheriff's deputy in California, used the department's Flock system to track a friend of his ex-fiancee after he had been arrested for kidnapping the ex-fiancee. In December 2025 a jury convicted him on multiple charges. The Institute for Justice lists his case among at least eighteen in which officers allegedly used automated plate readers to monitor romantic interests; Flock says such misuse is rare and that it has internal safeguards.
Flock searches tied to protest crackdownsUS
Data misuse
An analysis of 12 million Flock searches by 3,900 agencies found hundreds tied to political protests, including the No Kings and Hands Off demonstrations.
Flock cameras left streaming on the open internetUS
Data misuse
Security researchers found dozens of Flock cameras streaming live to the open internet without passwords, exposing live feeds and about a month of archived footage. Some logins later appeared on Russian cybercrime forums, and Senator Ron Wyden called for an FTC investigation while Flock called it a misconfiguration.
Plate reader used to ticket a phone-holding riderGA
Data misuse
Georgia State Patrol ticketed a motorcyclist for holding a cell phone, with the citation noting it was captured on a Flock camera, despite the vendor's claim that its readers are not used for traffic enforcement.
Casino face scan leads to a wrong arrestNV
Data misuse
Jason Killinger was arrested after a Reno casino's facial recognition flagged him as a banned trespasser. He and the real man had different eye colors, and the match did not hold up.
Police expand face search to petty crimesTX
Data misuse
Dallas police contracted Clearview AI in 2024 and used it 156 times in a year, then moved to expand face searches from serious felonies to misdemeanors such as theft and trespassing. The ACLU warned that running minor cases against the world's broadest scraped-face database is dangerous and prone to misidentification.
People-tracking cameras left open online, exposing kids at a playgroundUS
Data misuse
In December 2025, researcher Benn Jordan found roughly 60 Flock Condor cameras sitting open on the public internet with no password. Unlike Flock's plate-reading units, the Condor model is built to pan, tilt, zoom, and track people; among the exposed live feeds was footage of unattended children at a playground. Jordan showed the footage could be used to identify people by face or plate. Flock called it a limited misconfiguration that has since been fixed.
Pulled over again and again because of a typoCO
Wrongful stop
A Boulder County driver was repeatedly stopped by police after officers mistakenly entered her license plate onto a Flock hotlist. Nothing was wrong with the camera or her car. The plate simply sat on a list of vehicles to be flagged, and every camera she passed generated a fresh alert until somebody worked out why. Colorado produced three of these in five months -- Boulder County, Jefferson County and Cherry Hills -- which points at the absence of any routine review of what goes onto a hotlist or how it comes off.
80-plus agencies searched with anti-Romani slursUS
Data misuse
EFF found more than 80 agencies used anti-Romani slurs as search terms in the Flock network
Nearly 4 million warrantless Flock searchesCA
Data misuse
San Jose and other California agencies searched San Jose's Flock database nearly 4 million times in a year, prompting an EFF and ACLU lawsuit over warrantless searches.
Border Patrol's secret nationwide plate-reader dragnetUS
Data misuse
An AP investigation found Border Patrol had secretly built a nationwide network of plate readers, supplemented by the DEA and private vendors including Vigilant and Rekor, flagging movement it deemed suspicious and having local police make pretext stops.
City runs 500 plate readers, searched without warrantsCA
Data misuse
San Jose police blanketed the city with nearly 500 plate readers, kept the data for a year, and let officers statewide search it without a warrant. EFF and the ACLU sued, arguing the warrantless searches violate the California Constitution.
Oklahoma: are ALPRs even legal outside insurance checks?OK
Wrongful stop
At an Oklahoma House Public Safety Committee interim study on Oct 16, 2025, Rep. Tom Gann (R-Inola) argued that ALPRs in Oklahoma may STATUTORILY be used only to check whether a motorist carries auto insurance -- the purpose the legislature authorized in 2013 with HB 1792, the Oklahoma Temporary Motorist Liability Plan, passed to cut the state's uninsured-driver rate. On that reading, every investigative Flock deployment in the state is operating outside its statutory authority. Note precisely what this is: a legislator's argument at a committee study, not a court holding and not an attorney general opinion -- no ruling has tested it. But it is a live legal question rather than a policy preference, and it applies statewide. Speakers included University of Tulsa law professor Shena Burgess and former Logan County commissioner Marven Goodman, who described how ALPR data combines with other records into a "mosaic" tracking a person's movements whether or not they are suspected of anything. This matters directly for the deferred Oklahoma City Flock renewal: OKC, Edmond, Harrah, Jenks and Tulsa all run ALPRs, and if the statutory argument has force it reaches all of them at once, which no single council vote can do.
Internal audit caught an officer tracking a colleagueFL
Data misuse
Coty Hall, a former Niceville, Florida police officer, pleaded no contest to several charges after using the department's Flock system to track another officer and that officer's spouse. Unlike most cases in the Institute for Justice's review, his misconduct was discovered through an internal audit; he was fired following his arrest in October 2025.
Three held at gunpoint over false Flock alertsNM
Data misuse
Three people, including two minors, were held at gunpoint after erroneous Flock alerts
State sued a city over out-of-state ALPR sharingCA
Data misuse
The California attorney general sued the city after it shared ALPR data with more than 100 agencies in other states; its data was used in immigration-related searches over 500 times in a year.
Police shared data despite a shield lawMA
Data misuse
Despite a Massachusetts shield law on abortion and gender care, police shared driver-movement data with Flock's network of 7,000 agencies.
Sheriff found violating state plate-reader lawCA
Data misuse
The Humboldt County, California Sheriff was found violating state license plate reader laws governing how the data is shared and protected.
State sued the city over nationwide data sharingCA
Data misuse
In October 2025 California Attorney General Rob Bonta sued the City of El Cajon for sharing license-plate-reader data with more than 100 out-of-state and federal law-enforcement agencies across 26 states, in violation of California's SB 34. The city refused repeated warnings to stop, and the attorney general filed a further motion to compel compliance in February 2026.
Police tracked an op-ed writer with plate readersKS
Wrongful stop
After Lenexa resident Canyen Ashworth published a Kansas City Star op-ed on Sept. 30, 2025 criticizing the police department's role in ICE operations, Lenexa police opened an investigation and used the city's ALPRs to track his movements, issuing a BOLO tying him to anti-ICE posters. He was never the person in the video and was never charged.
Sergeant ran plates to build a commercial productGA
Data misuse
Every other misuse record on this map is an officer looking up a person. This one is an officer mining the network as a business input. Sandy Springs reserve Sergeant Francis Esposito, with the department since 2016 and promoted in 2021, ran license plates on his city Flock login and, the city's investigation concluded, passed the data to Signal 8 -- a Canton-based public-safety software startup he also worked for, founded by a former Sandy Springs detective who did not respond to reporters. The inquiry began with a whistleblower, a former Signal 8 employee, who told investigators the Flock data had been used for beta testing and product validation. Investigators concluded Esposito may have violated several Georgia laws including corporate espionage. He declined to answer their questions and resigned in Aug 2025; the city records the outcome as a termination and referred him to the Georgia Peace Officer Standards and Training Council, which can bar him from law enforcement permanently. THE OTHER SIDE, recorded because a record is not a verdict: Signal 8 denies instructing him to run any plates, says he acted on his own, and states that no Flock or City of Sandy Springs data was ever shared, transmitted or transferred to the company. The resignation-versus-termination discrepancy is left as it stands in the documents. Why it generalises: the value of a municipal ALPR network to a private firm is a motive that audit rules written around personal snooping were not designed to catch.
Chief mapped women's movements to harass themGA
Data misuse
A police chief was arrested after using readers to stalk women and send them maps of their own movements
Grant fraud and a false FBI compliance sign-offIA
Data misuse
After Iowa's Department of Public Safety investigated a complaint that Story County had applied a criminal-justice-information grant to a Flock contract without the required security compliance, Flock's security chief signed a federal CJIS certification despite knowing the company's devices failed basic requirements, and a state grant official backdated the missing paperwork while calling the complaint unfounded.
ICE face-scan app handed to local policeUS
Data misuse
A leaked DHS Privacy Threshold Analysis revealed the ICE Task Force Module (also called Mobile Identify), a phone app that lets roughly 1,300 local 287(g) officers scan the faces of people they stop and match them against more than 250 million government records, including visa and TSA traveler photos. It launched in September 2025 alongside ICE and CBP's own Mobile Fortify app.
Blamed for a string of thefts on a misread of the footageCO
Wrongful stop
An officer in the Denver area misinterpreted Flock captures and identified an innocent woman as responsible for a series of thefts. The camera worked; the reading of its output did not. IJ classifies roughly two thirds of the cases in its national review this way -- not machine failure but officers entering wrong information or drawing unsupported conclusions from what the system showed them, which is the part no accuracy percentage from a vendor can address.
Border Patrol tapped local cameras without sign-offWA
Data misuse
Records obtained by the University of Washington Center for Human Rights found that U.S. Border Patrol had apparent back-door access from May to August 2025 to Flock plate-reader networks run by at least ten Washington police departments that had never authorized immigration searches, and that at least eight agencies enabled direct sharing with Border Patrol. Washington limits local cooperation with immigration enforcement; researchers warned that the national network let federal agents and out-of-state police search local movement data, including searches tied to immigration. Flock and CBP described some of the access as a limited pilot.
Border Patrol got back-door access to WA networksWA
Data misuse
Border Patrol gained front-door, back-door, and side-door access to at least ten Washington police Flock networks that never authorized immigration sharing.
Secret pilot gave CBP access to ALPR dataCO
Data misuse
An undisclosed Flock pilot let Customs and Border Protection pull ALPR data from agencies that never intended to share with federal authorities.
Arrested on a Florida FACES false matchFL
Data misuse
Beau Burgess was wrongfully arrested in August 2025 after Florida's statewide FACES facial-recognition system, run by the Pinellas County Sheriff, flagged him as a suspect. It was one of several Florida wrongful arrests traced to the same system.
A third Colorado driver on a hotlist by mistakeCO
Wrongful stop
A Jefferson County driver was repeatedly pulled over after officers mistakenly placed her license plate on a Flock hotlist -- the same failure that hit Boulder County four months later and Cherry Hills the following spring. Three separate Colorado jurisdictions, the same mechanism, no camera malfunction involved in any of them. The error is administrative and it is the kind that persists until the person it happens to complains loudly enough to get it traced.
Sergeant sent Flock images to the FBIVA
Data misuse
A sergeant broke policy by sending Flock images to an FBI agent across state lines
Officer tracked an ex hundreds of times in two monthsKY
Data misuse
Roberto Cedeno, a Louisville, Kentucky police officer, was charged in 2025 with multiple felonies after allegedly using the city's automated plate-reader system to track an ex-partner and her friends hundreds of times over two months. His case appears in the Institute for Justice's review of at least eighteen incidents of officers using plate readers to follow romantic interests.
Axon's AI hides who wrote police reportsUS
Data misuse
EFF found that Axon's Draft One, which writes police reports from body-camera audio, deletes its drafts so no record shows what the AI wrote versus the officer. King County, Washington and others barred police from using AI to write reports.
Two months jailed on a false face matchND
Data misuse
Angela Lipps was arrested by US Marshals in Tennessee in July 2025 on a warrant from Fargo, North Dakota police who relied on a facial-recognition misidentification. She spent roughly two months in jail -- the longest of the known US face-recognition wrongful arrests -- losing her home, car, and dog before charges were dismissed. The Fargo police chief publicly apologized in March 2026.
Guns drawn on grandparents over a misread plateTN
Data misuse
Police drew their weapons on grandparents traveling with their 3-year-old granddaughter after a misread plate
Nearly 3,000 searches used ICE-related termsVA
Data misuse
Network audit logs in Bridgewater and Mecklenburg County, Virginia showed nearly 3,000 Flock searches using terms like 'ICE,' 'ERO,' and 'deportee.'
Sheriff ran plate searches for Border PatrolCA
Data misuse
An audit of plate-data searches showed the Orange County Sheriff ran queries on behalf of Customs and Border Protection or the Border Patrol, among ten Southern California agencies searching plate data on ICE's behalf.
Sheriff ran plate searches for CBPCA
Data misuse
An audit of plate-data searches showed the San Diego County Sheriff ran queries on behalf of Customs and Border Protection, part of a pattern of Southern California agencies searching plate data for immigration enforcement.
Federal immigration queried Bend's plate readers 279 timesOR
Wrongful stop
Reporting found that federal immigration authorities queried the Bend Police Department's Flock ALPR database 279 times in June 2025, in apparent violation of Oregon's sanctuary law barring local agencies from assisting immigration enforcement. The disclosure helped drive Bend's move to end its Flock program and fed the push for a statewide ALPR law.
Deputy searched 83,000 cameras to track an abortionTX
Data misuse
A sheriff's deputy in Johnson County, Texas used Flock's national lookup to search more than 83,000 cameras nationwide for a woman his office suspected of a self-managed abortion, logging the reason as a missing-person check. The searches swept up plate data from agencies in states where abortion is legal, including Washington. After 404 Media reported it, Flock added filters blocking abortion and immigration searches, and a bipartisan group in Congress called it a gross misuse of surveillance technology. The sheriff said his office was trying to protect the woman's safety.
Flock searched nationwide over a self-managed abortionTX
Wrongful stop
A Johnson County, Texas sheriff's office searched more than 83,000 Flock ALPR cameras nationwide while investigating a woman who had a self-managed abortion, logging the reason as 'had an abortion, search for female'. Records later showed deputies had consulted prosecutors about charging her.
ICE ran 4,000-plus Flock lookups with no contractUS
Data misuse
ICE, which holds no Flock contract, had local police run more than 4,000 nationwide Flock lookups on its behalf for immigration enforcement.
Plate readers used for school-residency checksOH
Data misuse
Delhi Township police in Ohio ran 35 plate-reader searches tied to students at five schools over three months to check residency, and defended the practice.
489,000 searches of one county's plate data in a monthCA
Data misuse
An audit of the Riverside County, California Sheriff's Flock system showed roughly 489,000 searches in a single month, including searches referencing Customs and Border Protection and Homeland Security Investigations cases.
Private network runs live face scans on Bourbon StLA
Data misuse
For two years New Orleans police secretly received real-time facial-recognition alerts from Project NOLA, a private nonprofit running more than 200 face-scanning cameras around the French Quarter, circumventing a city ordinance that barred live face surveillance. After the Washington Post exposed it in 2025, the department paused the automated alerts.
Officer ran one woman's plate nearly 400 timesMO
Data misuse
An officer ran one woman plate nearly 400 times, about a quarter of the department searches, with bogus reasons
Police ran plate readers to check school residencyGA
Data misuse
Police in Buford, Georgia ran license plate reader searches across more than 5,800 networks nationwide to verify whether families lived within a school zone, exposing where people worship, seek care, and travel.
Held two days despite an obvious mismatchNY
Data misuse
New York police arrested Trevis Williams on a facial-recognition match even though he was about eight inches taller and seventy pounds heavier than the actual suspect. He spent two days in jail, and civil-rights groups demanded a review of NYPD facial recognition.
Out-of-state agencies ran ICE searches of KyleTX
Data misuse
Agencies from 10 states ran at least 117 immigration-related searches of Kyle, Texas Flock cameras, more than half flagged 'ICE.'
Flock told police to hide case numbers from recordsCA
Data misuse
In a form email, Flock advised the Ridgecrest, California police department to keep search reasons as vague as permissible, and the department disabled case numbers in its public transparency portal, obscuring whether ALPR searches were tied to real investigations.
Chief stalked women seeking protective ordersGA
Data misuse
Braselton, Georgia police chief Michael Steffman resigned and was arrested in 2025 after several people, including women who had sought protective orders, accused him of using Flock cameras to follow them through neighborhoods and even send them maps of their own movements. Prosecutors charged him with stalking and related counts.
Officer tracked a woman he was dating 180 timesWI
Data misuse
A Milwaukee police officer, Josue Ayala, used the department's Flock network to track a woman he was dating and her ex-partner nearly 180 times, logging the vague reason investigation, a term the department used more than a thousand times in 2025. The conduct came to light not through any internal audit but because the victim found her plate on HaveIBeenFlocked.com, a site that aggregates released Flock search logs. He was charged with misconduct in office.
Sheriff searched for his wife's vehicle hundreds of timesID
Data misuse
Jerome County, Idaho sheriff George Oppedyk used a Flock system to search for his wife's vehicle hundreds of times. The state attorney general found no crime, and he retired in 2026, two years before his term ended.
Deputy tracked a coworker he was datingWI
Data misuse
Kenosha County, Wisconsin sheriff's deputy Frank McGrath resigned with severance after internal investigators found he used the department's Flock system to keep tabs on a coworker with whom he was romantically involved.
Officer charged with tracking his ex-girlfriendWI
Data misuse
Menasha, Wisconsin officer Cristian Morales was placed on leave and charged with misconduct in office after his ex-girlfriend reported that he used a Flock system to track her.
Deputy resigned after tracking a coworkerWI
Data misuse
Frank McGrath, a Kenosha County sheriff's deputy in Wisconsin, resigned with severance in 2025 after investigators found he had used the department's Flock system to track a coworker. The case is part of the Institute for Justice's review of officers misusing plate-reader networks for personal reasons.
Officer indicted on 23 counts of Flock misuseTN
Data misuse
Former Oak Ridge officer Zachary Gauthier was indicted on 23 counts of official misconduct, including 18 for misusing the Flock system for personal reasons.
Drones flown proactively over crowds and protestsNY
Data misuse
New York City's Drone as First Responder program flies proactively over parks, large gatherings, and demonstrations. In a November 2024 briefing a deputy commissioner said that when no 911 call is pending he expects the drone team to launch over runners, crowds, and protests -- which the ACLU warns turns emergency drones into routine aerial surveillance.
Officer ran an ex's plate dozens of timesFL
Data misuse
Orange City, Florida officer Jarmarus Brown ran his ex-girlfriend's license plate through Flock at least 69 times during the summer of 2024, plus her parents' plates dozens more, court records show, so often that a colleague noticed him doing it from his cruiser. He was arrested and charged in 2025 with stalking and improper computer access. It is one of at least 18 cases the Institute for Justice documented of officers using plate readers to track romantic interests, most surfacing only after victims complained.
Deputy tracked his ex-wife 100-plus timesTN
Data misuse
Shelby County, Tennessee deputy Thadius Gordon was relieved of duty after allegedly using an ALPR database to track his ex-wife's location more than 100 times.
Flagged for a crime 300 miles from homeFL
Data misuse
A Pinellas County FACES facial-recognition search flagged Robert Dillon, a Fort Myers man who lives more than 300 miles away and had never been to Jacksonville Beach, as a suspect in a 2024 child-enticement case. An ALPR search showed his car was never near the scene. Charges were dropped and he sued in June 2026.
Guns drawn in a Chick-fil-A drive-throughIN
Wrongful stop
Lafayette police detained an innocent man at gunpoint in a Chick-fil-A drive-through after a Flock camera misread his license plate. He sued the department. The location is worth recording rather than treating as colour: a felony stop executed in a queue of cars at a fast-food window puts bystanders inside the encounter, and the decision to run it there followed from a computer hit nobody had confirmed.
Officer ran an ex-partner's plate 69 timesFL
Data misuse
An officer ran his ex-girlfriend plate at least 69 times and put a GPS tracker in her wallet
Teenager handcuffed at gunpoint over a reader stopSC
Wrongful stop
In May 2024, Myrtle Beach, South Carolina police held a Black teenager at gunpoint and handcuffed her after a license-plate reader led officers to stop her vehicle. She filed a civil-rights lawsuit alleging the officers wrongfully detained her and knew before drawing their weapons that they had pulled over the wrong vehicle.
Mauled by a police dog after a plate misreadOH
Wrongful stop
In April 2024, Toledo, Ohio police pulled over Brandon Upchurch after a Flock plate reader misread a 7 on his license plate as a 2 and flagged his vehicle. He was attacked by a police dog, accused of resisting, and spent time in jail before the error came to light. Business Insider and the Toledo Blade documented the stop as one of several wrongful detentions caused by plate-reader misreads.
Man hurt by K-9 after Flock misread his plateOH
Data misuse
A man was hospitalized with police K-9 wounds after Flock misread his plate, and later lost his job and home
A tinted plate cover was blamed for the gunpoint stopSC
Wrongful stop
An innocent motorist was detained at gunpoint in York County after a Flock ALPR misread a character on his plate and flagged the car as stolen. The sheriff's office attributed the misread to a tinted license plate cover. That explanation is the interesting part, because it shifts responsibility to the driver for an accessory sold legally in most states -- and it concedes that the system's output is unreliable enough that a plastic cover can put someone at gunpoint.
Police chief tracked an ex 228 timesKS
Data misuse
Lee Nygaard, then police chief of Sedgwick, Kansas, used Flock plate-reader cameras to track his ex-girlfriend's vehicles 228 times over more than four months in 2024, and at one point followed her and her new boyfriend in his police car. The case is among several in Kansas and nationwide in which officers in positions of trust turned the surveillance network on people they had personal grievances with.
Father and daughter handcuffed after a plate typoFL
Wrongful stop
On New Year's Day 2024 in the Tampa Bay area, a father and his daughter, who has epilepsy, were handcuffed and held at gunpoint after an officer made a typo while running their license plate through a plate-reader database, according to WTSP. The error wrongly flagged their vehicle before officers realized the mistake.
Deputy tracked his ex-fiancee's friend via FlockCA
Data misuse
Riverside County, California deputy Alexander Vanny, arrested for kidnapping his ex-fiancee, used the department's Flock system to track one of her friends. He was convicted of multiple charges in 2025.
Officer ran hundreds of searches for an ex-partnerIL
Data misuse
Matteson, Illinois officer Jaila Cole-Clark ran hundreds of Flock searches for a former domestic partner and that person's new partner, and resigned during the investigation.
Retail face match jails an innocent man, assaulted in custodyTX
Wrongful stop
Harvey Eugene Murphy Jr., a 61-year-old grandfather, was wrongly jailed after facial-recognition software used by Sunglass Hut's parent EssilorLuxottica and retail partner Macy's falsely identified him as the gunman in a January 2022 armed robbery of a Houston Sunglass Hut. Murphy had been living in Sacramento, California at the time; when he returned to Texas to renew his license he was arrested in October 2023, denied bond, and held in the Harris County Jail, where three men sexually assaulted him before prosecutors verified his alibi and dropped the charges. His January 2024 lawsuit seeking $10 million spotlighted the dangers of low-quality footage, decades-old mugshots, and private companies steering police with unaccountable face matches.
Deputy tracked his ex-wife more than 100 timesTN
Data misuse
Thadius Gordon, a Shelby County sheriff's deputy in Tennessee, was relieved of duty in 2024 after allegedly using an automated plate-reader database to track his ex-wife's location more than a hundred times. The case is one of at least eighteen documented by the Institute for Justice in which officers allegedly used plate readers to monitor partners or exes; most came to light only after victims reported being stalked rather than through internal audits.
Wrongful arrest despite clearing evidenceMO
Wrongful stop
Christopher Galtin was wrongfully arrested in St. Louis after a face-recognition misidentification, and jailed even though readily available evidence showed he was not the correct match.
Miami wrongful arrest from a face matchFL
Wrongful stop
Jason Vernau was wrongfully arrested in Miami after being misidentified by face recognition, and jailed despite available evidence that he was not the correct match. The local department had told Congress it does not arrest on face recognition alone.
Handcuffed after a plate-reader dragnet for a car modelMI
Wrongful stop
Detroit police knew a shooting involved a Dodge Charger, then used plate readers to list every Charger in the area. Officers went to Isoke Robinson home, handcuffed her, placed her two-year-old in a patrol car, and impounded her car for three weeks, even though it had been recorded two miles from the shooting.
23 million Californians' plate data sold by repo-truck vendorTX
Data misuse
A California class action, Mata v. DRN, alleges Digital Recognition Network -- Motorola's commercial plate-scanning arm and Vigilant's sister company -- broke state law by mounting cameras on repo and private vehicles and selling roughly 23 million Californians' location data to insurers, lenders, and repossession firms.
Chief tracked his ex more than 200 timesKS
Data misuse
A police chief tracked his ex and her new boyfriend more than 200 times and lost his certification
Child handcuffed after a plate misreadNM
Wrongful stop
Police in Espanola detained Jaclynn Gonzales at gunpoint and placed her twelve-year-old sister in a patrol car after a plate reader misread the last digit of the plate, a 2 read as a 7, according to a lawsuit against the city.
Family held at gunpoint after a plate-entry typoTX
Wrongful stop
In July 2023, Frisco, Texas police held an Arkansas family at gunpoint on the Dallas North Tollway and handcuffed a child after an officer mistyped their license plate's state when running it, wrongly flagging their car as stolen. A sergeant arrived, caught the error, and called off the high-risk stop. The police chief apologized and opened a review, saying the department would not hide from its mistakes; the family, who were driving to a youth basketball tournament, hired a lawyer.
A teenager at gunpoint after officers typed it in wrongNM
Wrongful stop
In the same month that Espanola officers stopped two sisters over a misread digit, a separate stop in the same town put an innocent teenager at gunpoint -- this time because officers had entered incorrect information into the ALPR system themselves. Two gunpoint detentions of young people in one small New Mexico city in one month, one caused by the machine and one by the people operating it. The sisters sued; their case is recorded separately on this map.
Family stopped at gunpoint with a toddler aboardTN
Wrongful stop
In June 2023 in Morristown, Tennessee, a Flock plate reader misread an O as a 0 and flagged the Herron family's vehicle, leading officers to pull them over at gunpoint with their three-year-old granddaughter in the car. The family, on their way to a doctor, said they posed no threat. Business Insider and local reporting cited the stop among cases where plate-reader errors put innocent drivers at gunpoint.
Lieutenant used Flock to stalk his wifeKS
Data misuse
A lieutenant pleaded guilty to stalking after using Flock to track his estranged wife
A plate left on a hotlist after the reason was goneOH
Wrongful stop
Jackson Township officers pulled over and detained an innocent driver because they had failed to remove a license plate from a hotlist. The case is documented in federal court filings rather than only in news coverage, which makes it one of the better-evidenced examples of the pattern: a hotlist is easy to add to and nobody owns the job of taking things off it. The same failure produced the Greenville and Hercules detentions.
Pregnant woman wrongly arrested via face matchMI
Wrongful stop
Porcha Woodruff, eight months pregnant, was wrongfully arrested in Detroit in February 2023 for carjacking and robbery after a face-recognition match. She was detained for hours before being released, and the charges were later dropped.
Pregnant woman arrested on a false face matchMI
Data misuse
Detroit police arrested Porcha Woodruff, eight months pregnant, for a carjacking after facial recognition flagged her. The surveillance footage showed no pregnant woman, and the case was dismissed weeks later.
Arrested for an out-of-state crime via face matchGA
Wrongful stop
Randal Reid was arrested near Atlanta in November 2022 for a Louisiana purse theft he did not commit, after a Louisiana agency used a face-recognition match. He spent several days in jail before the warrants were withdrawn.
Arrested in one state for a crime in anotherLA
Data misuse
Georgia police arrested Randal Quran Reid on a Louisiana warrant after a Clearview AI face search wrongly matched him to a theft. Reid had never been to Louisiana and spent nearly a week in jail before release.
Face-recognition match leads to wrongful jailingMD
Wrongful stop
Alonzo Sawyer was wrongfully jailed in Maryland in 2022 after face-recognition software identified him as the man who assaulted a bus driver. He was held for nine days before the real suspect was identified.
Jailed nearly a year on a ShotSpotter alertIL
Data misuse
Michael Williams was jailed in Chicago for nearly a year on a murder charge built largely on a ShotSpotter alert. Prosecutors dropped the case in 2021 for insufficient evidence. His ordeal became a touchstone in the campaign against acoustic gunshot detection.
Teacher arrested at gunpoint over a plate-reader name errorNC
Wrongful stop
In June 2021, Charlotte-Mecklenburg police surrounded teacher Jasmine Horne outside her west Charlotte home and arrested her at gunpoint after a license plate reader linked her car to a wanted suspect because the system had been given the wrong name. She was handcuffed and held before officers realized they had the wrong person; the actual suspect was arrested two days later. An internal review found the officers acted within department policy and in good faith, while Horne, who filed a complaint, said the experience left her traumatized; the department later said it would check plate-reader entries more often and bring in outside review.
Held at gunpoint after a plate-reader letter mix-upCA
Wrongful stop
In Atherton, California, police pulled over Jason Burkleo on his way to work on suspicion of driving a stolen vehicle and ordered him at gunpoint to lie on his stomach to be handcuffed. The plate reader had misread an H as an M. Officers acted on the alert without confirming the plate, one of a string of documented reader misreads that have put innocent drivers at gunpoint.
Arrested at a laundromat over a phantom gunshotIL
Wrongful stop
Daniel Ortiz was doing his children's laundry when Chicago police, responding to a ShotSpotter alert for gunfire that never happened, detained and arrested him on charges that were dismissed the next day.
Boy killed after a ShotSpotter responseIL
Wrongful stop
Thirteen-year-old Adam Toledo was shot and killed by a Chicago police officer responding to a ShotSpotter alert in March 2021. The case became central to the city's decision to decommission the gunshot-detection system.
Officer pleaded guilty to stalking his estranged wifePA
Data misuse
Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania officer Michael McSherry pleaded guilty to stalking after using license plate readers to track his estranged wife and other family members.
Officer pleaded guilty to tracking his estranged wifePA
Data misuse
Michael McSherry, a police officer in Westmoreland County, Pennsylvania, pleaded guilty in 2021 to stalking charges after using plate readers to track his estranged wife and other family members. It is one of the earlier cases in the Institute for Justice's review of officers misusing automated plate-reader networks to follow people in their personal lives.
Predictive policing program harassed familiesFL
Data misuse
The Pasco County Sheriff's Office ran a predictive-policing program that generated lists of likely future offenders, then sent deputies to repeatedly harass roughly 1,000 residents and their families with late-night visits and code-enforcement fines. The office settled a lawsuit, admitted it violated residents' rights, and ended the program.
Family held at gunpoint over a plate-reader errorCO
Wrongful stop
Aurora police pulled over Brittney Gilliam and four children, including a six-year-old, at gunpoint and forced them face-down on the pavement after a plate reader flagged the SUV as stolen. The system had matched the Colorado plate to a stolen motorcycle with the same number from Montana. The city later settled the family lawsuit for 1.9 million dollars.
Drivers held at gunpoint over plate-reader errorsCO
Wrongful stop
License-plate-reader misreads have repeatedly put innocent drivers at gunpoint. In 2020 Aurora, Colorado police forced a Black woman and four children, the youngest six, face-down on hot pavement after a reader matched their plate to a stolen motorcycle from another state; the city paid 1.9 million dollars. CBS News verified more than a dozen US wrongful stops, including a 12-year-old handcuffed in New Mexico over a single misread digit and a San Francisco woman seized at gunpoint in 2009, and one study found readers misread the state on roughly 1 in 10 plates.
Spy plane filmed the entire city from aboveMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police ran a months-long aerial surveillance program in 2020, flying planes that continuously photographed the whole city to track people and vehicles. A federal appeals court later ruled the warrantless program unconstitutional.
Jailed nearly a year over a false gunshot alertIL
Wrongful stop
Michael Williams, 65, spent nearly a year in Cook County Jail after Chicago police charged him with murder based mainly on a ShotSpotter alert the system had first flagged as a firework. Prosecutors dropped the case, and in 2026 the city paid him 500,000 dollars; Chicago scrapped the system in 2024.
Auditor found ICE agencies in county plate dataCA
Data misuse
A California state auditor found that confusing Vigilant settings had left three different ICE agencies with access to the Marin County Sheriff's plate-reader data, frustrating a state law that limits cooperation with immigration enforcement.
Wrongful arrest from a face-recognition matchMI
Wrongful stop
Detroit police wrongfully arrested Robert Williams in January 2020 after face-recognition software matched him to surveillance footage of a shoplifter. He was held overnight; the case became the first widely known wrongful arrest tied to the technology and led Detroit to tighten its rules.
Border agency bought phone location data to skip warrantsUS
Wrongful stop
Customs and Border Protection paid millions to data brokers Venntel and Babel Street for commercial smartphone location data, running tens of thousands of queries to track devices without warrants as a workaround to the Carpenter ruling.
State handed a surveillance firm its databasesUT
Wrongful stop
Utah gave the firm Banjo a multimillion-dollar contract and access to state databases, including traffic cameras and 911 feeds, before a government audit found the company could not deliver the real-time crime detection it had promised.
Mother handcuffed in an ALPR dragnet for a car modelMI
Wrongful stop
Detroit police used plate readers to list every Dodge Charger near a shooting, then handcuffed Isoke Robinson, put her 2-year-old in a patrol car, and impounded her car for three weeks, though she was two miles away.
Wrongful arrests from false face matchesMI
Wrongful stop
At least fourteen people in the US are publicly known to have been wrongfully arrested after police relied on a false facial-recognition match, beginning with Robert Williams in Detroit in 2020. Nearly all were Black; the cases include a woman who was eight months pregnant and several people jailed for months over crimes in states they had never set foot in.
Detroit man wrongly arrested by face matchMI
Data misuse
Robert Williams was arrested at his Detroit-area home after facial recognition wrongly matched him to a watch-store theft. He was held overnight on the strength of a bad match and a photo lineup built around it. His case became the first known US facial-recognition wrongful arrest and ended in a landmark settlement forcing Detroit police to curb the technology.
Detained over a stale stolen-car flagCA
Wrongful stop
Contra Costa sheriff deputies stopped Brian Hofer and his brother at gunpoint on Thanksgiving after a plate reader flagged the car as stolen, even though the vehicle had already been recovered and police had not updated the hot list. Hofer chaired a local privacy commission and received a settlement of about 49,500 dollars.
Privacy advocate detained over a stale stolen-car hitCA
Wrongful stop
Privacy advocate Brian Hofer and his brother were detained at gunpoint on Thanksgiving 2019 after a plate reader flagged his car as stolen, though it had already been recovered and never removed from the hot list.
Face-recognition misidentification, charges droppedMI
Wrongful stop
Michael Oliver was wrongfully arrested in Detroit in 2019 after face recognition misidentified him as the person who threw a teacher's phone. Charges were dismissed once it was clear he was not the man in the video, and he later sued.
Perceptics: even the border agency's ALPR vendor got hackedUS
Wrongful stop
A cautionary tale from the ALPR industry's deep end: Perceptics, the plate-reader vendor for U.S. Customs and Border Protection -- arguably the best-funded law-enforcement agency in the country -- was hacked, and the stolen data, including traveler images and license plates, was published online. The EFF cites it as the definitive proof that ALPR databases are a breach waiting to happen: if CBP's vendor could be cracked and dumped, so can a small town's. The lesson holds across every vendor on this map -- Flock, Axon, Vigilant, Rekor, ELSAG, Jenoptik -- a plate database is only as safe as the least-secure company holding it.
Border plate-reader vendor hacked, traveler data leakedTN
Data misuse
Perceptics, the sole provider of license plate readers at US land border crossings, was hacked, exposing travelers' plate data and CBP photos of drivers that ended up online. CBP called it a major incident, and the vendor had been using the data to refine its algorithms.
Jailed ten days over a false face matchNJ
Wrongful stop
Nijeer Parks was wrongfully arrested in 2019 after New Jersey police relied on a face-recognition match tying him to shoplifting and an assault. He spent about ten days in jail despite being elsewhere at the time, and later sued.
Jailed six days over a Google location dragnetAZ
Wrongful stop
Police in Avondale, Arizona obtained a Google geofence warrant that swept up every device near a 2018 murder. Jorge Molina was arrested and held six days even after a detective quickly deemed him highly unlikely to be the killer; his stepfather was later charged.
Jailed ten days on a false face matchNJ
Data misuse
New Jersey police arrested Nijeer Parks after facial recognition wrongly tied him to a shoplifting and assault case, even though he was nowhere near the scene. He spent about ten days in jail before the charges were dropped.
Brothers held at gunpoint over a rental car already recoveredCA
Wrongful stop
A Vigilant ALPR in Hercules flagged a vehicle as stolen and officers detained the driver and his brother at gunpoint. The car had been recovered already; nobody had updated the hotlist. The driver was Brian Hofer, who chaired Oakland's privacy commission -- so the person the system stopped at gunpoint was among the few in the state best placed to explain publicly what had gone wrong, and he did. The New York Times covered it. IJ's review dates this to November 2018 and places it in Hercules, which resolves a disagreement in later accounts that put it variously in 2018 or 2019 and in Contra Costa County generally.
ICE pulled plate data from Irvine Company mallsCA
Data misuse
Vigilant cameras at Irvine Company shopping malls in Orange County fed plate data that ICE accessed through a fusion center, despite denials. The mall operator ended its plate-reader program after the practice was exposed.
ICE tapped Vigilant's plate database to track immigrantsUS
Data misuse
ICE gained access to Vigilant Solutions' database of more than 5 billion plate scans through a multi-year contract, letting over 9,000 officers reconstruct people's movements without a warrant to support deportations. The contract has since grown to $22.8 million.
Crime-prediction software hit under half a percentNJ
Wrongful stop
An analysis of more than 23,000 Geolitica (formerly PredPol) crime predictions for Plainfield, New Jersey found a success rate under half a percent, with fewer than 100 predictions matching a later-reported crime. The police captain said the money could have been better spent elsewhere.
Shot by police after a sound was reclassifiedNY
Wrongful stop
In Rochester, New York, Silvon Simmons was shot in the back by police after a ShotSpotter alert. The company's analysts had first classified the noise as a helicopter, then reclassified it as gunshots and raised the count on later reviews.
Police bought a cell tracker to watch protestersFL
Wrongful stop
Miami police purchased a cell-site simulator specifically to surveil political protesters, turning military-grade phone-tracking gear on demonstrators.
Palantir and PredPol drove chronic-offender scoringCA
Wrongful stop
The LAPD used Palantir's Gotham platform, PredPol hot-spot software, and Operation LASER's chronic-offender scores, built from arrest records, license plates, and social media. An inspector general and activists found the tools entrenched over-policing of Black and Latino neighborhoods; LASER ended in 2019 and the PredPol contract in 2020.
Fake cell towers used thousands of times in secretMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police secretly deployed cell-site simulators (Stingrays) more than 4,300 times to locate phones, routinely concealing the technology from courts and defense attorneys.
Face recognition and social media tracked protestersMD
Wrongful stop
Baltimore police used facial recognition combined with social-media location tracking to surveil and identify protesters after the 2015 death of Freddie Gray.
Plate readers concentrated in Black and Latino areasCA
Data misuse
An investigation of license plate readers in Oakland, California found them placed predominantly in Black and Latino neighborhoods, even though vehicle crimes occurred predominantly elsewhere.
Secret Palantir program ran for years off the booksLA
Wrongful stop
New Orleans police secretly used Palantir's Gotham predictive-policing software from 2012 to 2018 without the city council's knowledge, building target lists from criminal records, social media, and alleged gang ties under a philanthropic-partnership cover that bypassed procurement and oversight.
Plate readers used to surveil Muslim communitiesNY
Data misuse
The NYPD used license plate readers as part of its broad surveillance of Muslim communities across the New York and New Jersey area.
Handcuffed at gunpoint after a misread plateCA
Wrongful stop
San Francisco officers stopped Denise Green, a city worker, late at night and handcuffed her at gunpoint on her knees after a cruiser plate reader misread one digit and matched her car to a stolen vehicle. No officer confirmed the plate by eye. The city paid about 495,000 dollars, and the Ninth Circuit later held that a plate-reader hit alone, without human verification, cannot justify a stop.
Driver held at gunpoint after a misread plateCA
Wrongful stop
Denise Green was pulled over and held at gunpoint after a plate reader misread a 3 as a 7 on her plate and no officer checked before acting. San Francisco paid her $495,000.
Jailhouse exposure of secret cell trackersCA
Wrongful stop
The FBI used a Stingray cell-site simulator to locate Daniel Rigmaiden in his Santa Clara, California apartment in 2008. Working from a jail cell, he reverse-engineered the device and forced the FBI to publicly acknowledge the technology for the first time.
The DEA's national plate-reader networkUS
Data misuse
The Drug Enforcement Administration has run a national license plate reader network since 2008, expanding it into a nationwide tracking system with covert cameras, many using Selex and ELSAG hardware, strung along highways and accessible to other agencies.
Lieutenant pleaded guilty to stalking via plate readersKS
Data misuse
Victor Heiar, a police lieutenant in Kechi, Kansas, pleaded guilty to computer crime and stalking after using Flock cameras to monitor his estranged wife's movements over several months. His case appears in the Institute for Justice's tally of officers misusing automated plate-reader networks to track partners and exes.
Officer charged after an ex reported plate-reader trackingWI
Data misuse
Cristian Morales, a police officer in Menasha, Wisconsin, was placed on leave and charged with misconduct in office in 2025 after his ex-girlfriend filed a complaint alleging he used a Flock system to track her. It is one of at least eighteen cases the Institute for Justice has compiled of officers using automated plate readers to follow romantic interests.
Agencies buy app location data to skip warrantsUS
Data misuse
Federal agencies including ICE, CBP, the FBI, and the IRS bought app-harvested smartphone location data from brokers Venntel, Gravy Analytics, and Babel Street's Locate X to sidestep warrants. The FTC banned Gravy and Venntel from selling sensitive location data in December 2024.
Military buys app data to track people abroadUS
Data misuse
US defense contractors and agencies purchased commercial smartphone location data harvested from ordinary apps, including Muslim prayer apps via the broker X-Mode, to track people including in foreign jurisdictions for pattern-of-life analysis, sidestepping the rules that govern signals intelligence.